#1 The faith healing-couple who let their children die without medical intervention
Herbert and Catherine Schaible are members of a small Pentecostal community in Pennsylvania that believe in faith healing—the concept that if God wants someone to live, he will save them. They also believe using medicine is a way of ignoring God's will.
In 2009, the Schaible's lost their two-year-old to pneumonia, after insisting on praying for him, rather than taking him to a doctor. They were charged with involuntary manslaughter and sentenced to ten years probation, with the caveat that they must seek medical care if another child fell ill.
That didn't work. In 2014, they were brought before the yet court again with third-degree murder charges for refusing to take their eight-month-old to the doctor. The couple pleaded no contest and were sentenced to seven years in prison. Their seven surviving children were put in the care of relatives and foster parents.
#2 The parents that starved their child despite having plenty of food
Tivasha E. Logan and Chauncey Gardner had plenty of food in their home when their five-month-old daughter died of starvation. They also received food stamps, a $674 Social Security check each month specifically for the infant and were part of the county's Women, Infants & Children program, which provides formula for free to families. Despite this, they only had 2 ounces of formula in their home, and what they fed the baby, they watered down to a 3:1 ratio rather than the 1:1 ratio as specified in the directions.
When their baby was born, she was a healthy girl, weighing 7 pounds, eight ounces. In her short life, she was never taken to the doctor for a single check up. When she died, she weighed only six pounds—a pound and a half less than she weighed at birth, and less than half of what the average 5-month-old weighs. Tivasha told detectives that she didn't want to take her baby to the hospital because she was fearful of losing custody.
The couple had three children together and were also caring for two of Tivasha's children from a previous relationship. They had been investigated four times before, but authorities never found enough evidence to support removing the children from the couple's custody.
After the infant's death, the five children were put in the care of a relative. Tivasha and Chauncey were arrested and charged with first-degree murder and aggravated child abuse. Tivasha was sentenced to life without parole, while Chauncey, who claimed he no longer lived in the home full time and didn't know that his daughter was in such bad shape, was given a thirty-year sentence.
#3 The vegan couple who fed their infant soy milk and apple juice
Mammals all drink milk; it's what makes them mammals. But one vegan couple in Atlanta believed their child didn't need to survive on breast milk or formula. Instead, they fed their son 6-week-old son soy milk and apple juice. The child starved to death. His parents eventually took him to the hospital when he stopped breathing, but doctors couldn't resuscitate him. He weighed only 3.5 pounds when he died, which is what babies usually weigh while seven months into a pregnancy.
ParentsJade Sanders and Lamont Thomas were each sentenced to life for their son's murder. During the trial, they argued that they were innocent and were just being persecuted for their lifestyle.
#4 The vegans who fed their starving baby tomato juice and water
In 2001, Hasmik and Garabet Manuelyan were charged with gross neglect for letting their nine-month-old die from bronchopneumonia brought on by malnutrition. The couple fed their baby tomato juice and water and ignored a doctor warnings the child was dangerously sick the day before she died. He recommended the child receive immediate intravenous feeding, but the Manuelyan's left the clinic and said they would think about it. When the little girl passed away, she weighed only 11 pounds.
Despite having their other two children taken away by child protective services, and receiving multiple warnings by doctors and dieticians about the way they fed their newest daughter, the Manuelyans ignored insisted that they were following "the laws of nature."
Surprisingly, the Manuelyans were sentenced to only three years community service, because the judge felt the death of their youngest child, the lost custody of the older two kids, and the dissolution of the couple's marriage was punishment enough. "Your real punishment is that you will have to spend the rest of your lives in the knowledge that your stubbornness caused [your daughter's] death. For loving parents like you that is a crushing burden to bear," he said.
#5 The couple who let their child die of meningitis even after being told he should be hospitalized
Canadians David and Collet Stephan knew their 19 month-old was sick, but they mistakenly believed he just had a simple cold, so they treated him with home remedies like hot peppers, maple syrup, apple cider vinegar, garlic, onions, and horseradish. They kept up with these natural treatments even after the boy suffered for over two weeks, and even after a friend told them she thought the boy had meningitis and needed to be brought to a doctor ASAP.
When the family took the boy to a naturopathic clinic in Lethbridge to pick up an echinacea mixture, he was too stiff to ride in a car seat and had to lay down on a mattress. Despite this obvious emergency, the Stephans never brought him to a doctor until he stopped breathing. After spending five days on life support, he died.
The Stephans were charged with and found guilty of failing to provide the necessities of life to their child. Collet was sentenced to three months of house arrest, and David received four months in jail, as he demonstrated a lack of remorse and refused to acknowledge that his actions played a role in the boy's death.